The Foreign Policy Tool America Can’t Afford to Abandon: Why Foreign Assistance Still Matters to U.S. Security and Influence

In September 2025, Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times wrote about his visit to Uganda where he witnessed villages running out of food, public health initiatives collapsing, and people growing increasingly frail. Foreign assistance that was once provided by the United States Agency for International Development, USAID, is no longer available. Elon Musk and other members of the Trump administration disputed Kristof’s account and similar reporting. In an interview with The Economist, Musk argued that “zero people have died from USAID cuts.”
A year later, the U.S. Government Accountability Office published findings that detailed USAID operations essentially ending in July 2025 via executive orders, with the State Department assuming control over remaining functions. However, the report reveals that “State does not have documented guidance to ensure that its decisions about foreign assistance are consistent and effective”. The State Department also lacks complete and accurate data about foreign assistance awards, grants, and staffing. This data is critical to forming funding and program decisions.
Foreign assistance is neither inherently effective nor inherently wasteful. It is a tool of statecraft whose value depends on how strategically it is designed, implemented, and later evaluated. The United States is right to demand clear objectives, rigorous oversight, and measurable results but abandoning foreign assistance risks surrendering an important instrument of American security and influence.
Most Americans say that the United States spends too much on foreign assistance. When polled, nearly nine out of ten Americans stated that the country overspends on foreign assistance. On average, respondents said that 26% of the budget goes to foreign assistance. However, this is not the case. In reality, only around 1% of the U.S. budget goes to such programs. After hearing this figure, the number of respondents who said the U.S. spends too much on foreign assistance dropped by more than twenty percentage points.
This does not mean that every foreign assistance program is effective or that Washington should provide aid without scrutiny. Foreign assistance must be strategic and accountable. Thus, the question should not simply be how much the United States spends abroad, but whether those resources are being used effectively to advance American interests and address the problems they are intended to solve.
Foreign assistance has traditionally been viewed as a bipartisan success. Plan Colombia, initiated by President Bill Clinton and continued under President George W. Bush was launched with the intentions of supporting the Colombian government in combating drug trafficking, insurgency, and institutional fragility. Through a combination of military support and development assistance, American aid supported alternative livelihoods for farmers, improved governance in rural areas, and strengthened Colombian judicial and security institutions. Plan Colombia was able to transform Colombia from a near failed state into a more stable, functioning democracy. However, sustained vigilance is necessary to preserve the gains of the 2016 Peace Accord.
Seemingly distant developments still have the ability to implicate the United States. This is most evident in migration from Colombia and other Latin American countries, and increasingly in global health. At the time of writing, the Democratic Republic of the Congo has reported 8,728 confirmed cases, with the majority occurring in Ituri Province, according to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.
In May 2026, Director-General of the World Health Organization labeled the outbreak a Public Health Emergency of International Concern. This outbreak requires international coordination and cooperation in response as this outbreak is unfolding in a region rife with conflict, highly mobile populations, and large refugee communities. As such, Kenya has now confirmed its first Ebola case after a man who traveled to Congo passed away.
Lastly, if the United States continues to withdraw from foreign assistance programs, it risks creating greater space for other powers to expand their influence. Russia and China are already active across Africa, seeking to deepen their relationships throughout the continent.
Following the 2021 coup d’état in Mali, the new Malian government has reduced ties with the West and instead has pivoted towards Russia. In the summer of 2025, Mali and Russia signed a series of agreements aiming to expand mutual trade and strengthen economic ties. This reflects a broader trend in the region, with neighboring countries such as Burkina Faso and Niger also pivoting towards Russia.
Chinese companies have signed more than $700 billion in contracted projects in Africa over the past decade, while Beijing has also expanded its media and information presence across the continent. Not only are the Chinese investing in infrastructure but also media projects to shape public opinion. Through expanding partnerships with local outlets, Chinese media is increasingly establishing its presence across the continent, aiming to shape perceptions and present China as a model of development and governance. This strategy has seemingly been successful, with large sections of African media providing favorable coverage of China.
The United States therefore faces a choice. Foreign assistance should not be treated as charity, nor should it be immune from scrutiny. Programs must have clear objectives, measurable outcomes, and a demonstrable connection to American interests. But abandoning foreign assistance altogether risks sacrificing an important instrument of American statecraft at a time when instability, disease, and strategic competition increasingly disregard state borders. The United States does not need to spend indiscriminately abroad. It needs to be spent strategically. Foreign assistance, when properly designed and accountable, is not simply money sent overseas, rather an investment in U.S. security and influence.
This article written by James Calderon is a graduate student at Columbia University, pursuing a Master of International Affairs, with a focus on international security. He has held positions with the U.S. government, at the United Nations, and several research institutions, and has written extensively on international security issues.




Comments